New York's Strangest Museums: A Must-See Guide

Uncover New York's strangest secrets in these 10 bizarre museums. From gangsters to sex, prepare for a mind-bending cultural adventure!

NYC'S WEIRDEST MUSEUMS

Jordyn Wayfarer

7/31/20247 min read

Unveiling NYC's Hidden Gems: 10 Mind-Blowing Offbeat Museums You Won't Believe Exist!

Are you tired of the same old museum experiences? Prepare to have your mind blown as we take you on a wild ride through New York City's most shocking, bizarre, and downright unforgettable offbeat museums! From pickle-themed exhibits to underground subway secrets, these hidden gems will make your Instagram followers green with envy. Get ready to discover the Big Apple's weirdest and most wonderful cultural treasures!

1. The Museum of Sex: Not Your Grandma's History Lesson

Hold onto your hats, folks! The Museum of Sex is about to take you on a titillating journey through the history of human sexuality. This isn't your typical stuffy museum experience – it's a provocative exploration of everything from ancient fertility rituals to modern-day kink culture.

Why it's mind-blowing:

  • Interactive exhibits that'll make you blush

  • A "bouncy castle" of giant inflatable breasts (yes, really!)

  • The world's most extensive collection of sex-related artifacts

Pro tip: Looking for a wild night out? Book a guided tour with GetYourGuide for an even more in-depth (and hilarious) experience!

2. Mmuseumm: The World's Smallest Museum in an Elevator Shaft

Blink and you might miss it! Mmuseumm is a tiny museum crammed into an abandoned freight elevator in Tribeca. This micro-museum packs a big punch, showcasing quirky collections of everyday objects that tell fascinating stories about our world.

What makes it unique:

  • Rotating exhibits that fit in a space smaller than your closet

  • Objects ranging from fake fast food to ISIS currency

  • A gift shop that's literally a vending machine

3. City Reliquary: A Time Capsule of NYC's Weirdest Memorabilia

Step into a hoarder's paradise at the City Reliquary! This eclectic museum is a love letter to New York's strangest artifacts and forgotten history. From vintage subway tokens to chunks of famous buildings, it's a treasure trove of Big Apple oddities.

Must-see exhibits:

  • A collection of old-school seltzer bottles (because why not?)

  • Fragments of the Statue of Liberty's original torch

  • Soil samples from all five boroughs (for the true NYC dirt enthusiast)

4. Museum of the American Gangster: Sleep with the Fishes (Figuratively)

Fuhgeddaboudit! The Museum of the American Gangster is an offer you can't refuse. Housed in a former speakeasy, this museum takes you deep into the gritty underworld of organized crime in America.

Highlights:

  • John Dillinger's death mask (because normal museums are for suckers)

  • A vintage Tommy gun you can actually hold

  • Secret tunnels used for rum-running during Prohibition

Insider tip: After exploring the museum, grab a drink at the attached tavern – if these walls could talk, they'd probably get whacked!

5. The Elevator Historical Society: Going Up in the World of Vertical Transportation

You might be thinking, "An entire museum dedicated to elevators? That's crazy!" And you'd be right – crazy awesome! The Elevator Historical Society is a quirky tribute to the unsung heroes of vertical transportation.

What you'll learn:

  • The fascinating history of elevator music (it's more exciting than you think!)

  • How elevators shaped the modern skyline

  • Why elevator operators were once considered elite members of society

6. Museum of Interesting Things: Where Antiques Meet Mad Science

Imagine if your eccentric inventor uncle opened a museum – that's the Museum of Interesting Things in a nutshell. This traveling exhibition showcases weird and wonderful inventions from the past, present, and future.

Cool stuff you'll see:

  • Edison's first light bulb (it's not as bright as you'd expect)

  • Vintage medical devices that look more like torture instruments

  • Proto-computers that make your smartphone look like a supercomputer

7. The Troll Museum: A Nostalgia Trip for 90s Kids (and Weirdos)

UPDATE: Sadly, the original Troll Museum closed its doors in 2016. But fear not, troll enthusiasts! The collection has found a new home in various pop-up locations around the city. Keep your eyes peeled for these frizzy-haired creatures making appearances at local events and galleries.

Why it's worth tracking down:

  • Thousands of troll dolls in every size, shape, and color imaginable

  • The chance to meet Reverend Jen, the self-proclaimed "Troll Queen"

  • A healthy dose of 90s nostalgia (scrunchies and slap bracelets not included)

8. The Morbid Anatomy Museum: Where Death Becomes Art

IMPORTANT NOTE: The physical museum closed in 2016, but its spirit lives on! The Morbid Anatomy team continues to host events, lectures, and pop-up exhibitions around NYC and beyond.

What made it unforgettable:

  • A library dedicated to death, anatomy, and the occult

  • Taxidermy workshops for aspiring mad scientists

  • Lectures on topics like "The History of Medical Cannibalism" (yum?)

Stay connected: Follow their social media for updates on upcoming events and virtual exhibitions. It's like Halloween all year round!

9. The Torah Animal World: Noah's Ark Meets Natural History

Ever wondered what it would be like to step into a biblical petting zoo? Wonder no more! The Torah Animal World in Brooklyn is a taxidermy wonderland featuring every animal mentioned in the Old Testament.

What makes it wild:

  • Over 350 stuffed animals arranged in biblical scenes

  • A chance to touch and interact with the exhibits (yes, you can pet a lion!)

  • Guided tours that blend zoology with religious education

Plan ahead: This museum is by appointment only, so book your tour with Trip.com in advance for a truly unique experience!

10. The Houdini Museum: Escape the Ordinary

Abracadabra! The Houdini Museum in midtown Manhattan is a magical tribute to the world's most famous escape artist. Prepare to be amazed by the life and legacy of Harry Houdini.

Spellbinding features:

  • Houdini's original handcuffs and straightjackets

  • Live magic performances and escape demonstrations

  • The opportunity to try your hand at some of Houdini's famous tricks

Make it a weekend: After your magical adventure, book a nearby hotel with Expedia.com to extend your enchanting NYC getaway!

Conclusion: Embrace the Weird, Wonderful World of NYC's Offbeat Museums

New York City is more than just world-famous art galleries and historic institutions. These offbeat museums prove that the Big Apple's cultural scene is as diverse and eccentric as its residents. So, the next time you're in town, ditch the guidebook and dive into the wonderfully weird world of NYC's hidden museum gems!

Pro Travel Tip: Pack light and stay mobile with Travelpro luggage – the choice of airline crews worldwide. You'll need the extra space for all the quirky souvenirs you'll inevitably collect on your offbeat museum adventure!

Must-Read Resources for NYC Museum Enthusiasts

  1. 10 Secret Underground Spots in NYC That Will Blow Your Mind!

  2. The Ultimate Guide to Free Museum Days in New York City

  3. 5 Bizarre NYC Museums That Will Make You Question Reality

  4. Hidden Gems: Lesser-Known Museums in New York City

  5. The Weirdest and Wackiest Museums in America

Crowds taking a picture of an artwork in one of the unique museums in NYC
Crowds taking a picture of an artwork in one of the unique museums in NYC
The Museum of Sex, an offbeat NYC museum
The Museum of Sex, an offbeat NYC museum
Statue of Liberty, a hidden gem view from an offbeat NYC museum
Statue of Liberty, a hidden gem view from an offbeat NYC museum
Harry Houdini exhibit, a unique museum experience in NYC
Harry Houdini exhibit, a unique museum experience in NYC

Disclosure: Please note that some of the links above may be affiliate links, and at no additional cost to you, I earn a commission if you make a purchase. I recommend only products and companies I use and the income goes to keeping the site community supported and ad free.

Ready to elevate your travel experience? Discover Travelpro's exceptional range of luggage, trusted by airline professionals worldwide for over 20 years. With innovative designs and unmatched durability, Travelpro makes packing and navigating airports effortless. Visit Travelpro to find the perfect travel companion and journey with the confidence of a seasoned traveler.



Book Your Trip: Essential Tips and Tricks

Book Your Flight

Discover the best flight deals with Trip.com. It's our go-to search engine because it scours websites and airlines worldwide, ensuring you never miss out on the best prices.

Don't Skip Travel Insurance!

Protect your adventures with SafetyWing. We never leave home without coverage for illness, injuries, and unexpected events. Their Nomad Insurance is perfect for digital nomads and long-term travelers, offering global coverage at affordable rates. Give yourself peace of mind and explore worry-free!

Want to Travel for Free?

Travel credit cards can help you earn points for free flights and accommodations without any extra spending.

Pack Smart with TravelPro

For luggage that stands up to the rigors of adventure, we recommend TravelPro. Their innovative designs and durable construction have made them a favorite among frequent travelers and flight crews alike. Plus, with their 100-day trial and lifetime warranty, you can travel with confidence.

Plan Your Itinerary

Overwhelmed by choices? Consider using a trip planning service. They can help you create a personalized itinerary tailored to your interests, saving you time and ensuring you don't miss out on hidden gems.

Stay Connected

Don't forget to arrange for international data or a local SIM card. Staying connected can be crucial for navigation, last-minute bookings, and sharing your adventures with loved ones back home.

Ready to Book Your Trip?

Visit our resource page for the best travel companies. We list all the ones we personally use and trust. They are top-notch and you can't go wrong using them on your journey.

Remember, at Passport and Adventure, we're committed to helping you create unforgettable travel experiences. Whether you're planning a weekend getaway or a round-the-world adventure, these tips will help ensure your journey is as smooth and enjoyable as possible.

Happy travels!

gray computer monitor

GET YOUR FREE ULTIMATE TRAVEL PACKING CHECKLIST

Enter your email to receive our comprehensive packing guide. Never forget essential items again!

Start your journey prepared with Passport and Adventure!